MailSentinel vs Validity (Everest): DMARC Alternative Comparison
Compare MailSentinel and Validity (Everest) for DMARC monitoring. See why MailSentinel offers more focused DMARC capabilities at a better price point.
MailSentinel
Starting at $14/month
- Modern, intuitive dashboard
- Real-time alerts
- Transparent pricing
- Self-service signup
Validity
$500-5,000+/month
- Comprehensive deliverability platform
- Inbox placement testing
- Return Path integration
- Enterprise pricing
- Complex platform
- DMARC not primary focus
Feature Comparison
| Feature | MailSentinel | Validity |
|---|---|---|
| DMARC Report Parsing | ||
| SPF Monitoring | ||
| DKIM Monitoring | ||
| Real-time Alerts | ||
| Focused DMARC Tool | ||
| Transparent Pricing | ||
| Self-Service Signup | ||
| Inbox Placement Testing | ||
| Seed List Testing | ||
| Quick Deployment |
Why Consider a Validity Alternative for DMARC?
Validity (formerly Return Path and 250ok) is an enterprise email deliverability platform. Their Everest product offers comprehensive email analytics, including DMARC monitoring as part of a broader suite.
When Validity Makes Sense
Validity excels for organizations that need:
- Comprehensive inbox placement testing
- Seed list monitoring across ISPs
- Detailed deliverability analytics
- Enterprise-level support
When MailSentinel is Better
Many organizations find Validity is overkill when they primarily need:
- DMARC monitoring without full deliverability suite
- Affordable pricing for authentication focus
- Quick deployment without sales cycles
- Focused tool for email authentication
MailSentinel vs Validity: Feature Comparison
DMARC Capabilities
Both platforms offer solid DMARC monitoring:
| Capability | MailSentinel | Validity |
|---|---|---|
| Aggregate Reports | ✅ Full | ✅ Full |
| Forensic Reports | ✅ Full | ✅ Full |
| Real-time Alerts | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Historical Data | ✅ Unlimited | ✅ Varies |
| Source Analysis | ✅ Advanced | ✅ Advanced |
Where They Differ
Validity Offers:
- Inbox placement monitoring
- Seed list testing
- Comprehensive deliverability suite
- ISP relationship insights
MailSentinel Offers:
- Focused DMARC expertise
- Transparent, affordable pricing
- Instant self-service signup
- Modern, intuitive dashboard
Pricing Comparison
Validity Everest:
- Starting at $500+/month
- Custom enterprise pricing
- Annual contracts required
- Sales process required
MailSentinel:
- Starter: $14/month
- Professional: $49/month
- Month-to-month available
- Sign up in minutes
Cost Analysis
For DMARC-focused needs:
- Validity: $6,000-60,000+/year
- MailSentinel: $168-588/year
- Savings: $5,000-59,000+/year
Migration from Validity to MailSentinel
If you're currently using Validity primarily for DMARC:
- Keep Validity for inbox placement testing (if needed)
- Add MailSentinel for dedicated DMARC monitoring
- Update DMARC record to send reports to MailSentinel
- Evaluate ROI after 30 days
Many organizations use both tools:
- Validity for deliverability testing campaigns
- MailSentinel for day-to-day DMARC monitoring
The Bottom Line
- Choose Validity if you need comprehensive deliverability analytics and inbox testing
- Choose MailSentinel if you need focused, affordable DMARC monitoring
MailSentinel delivers better value for organizations whose primary need is email authentication monitoring.