MailSentinel vs GlockApps: Complete DMARC Monitoring Comparison

GlockApps vs MailSentinel: Different Tools for Different Needs

GlockApps and MailSentinel serve overlapping but distinct purposes in the email ecosystem. Understanding the difference is key to choosing the right tool.

What GlockApps Does

GlockApps is primarily an email testing platform that includes:

• Inbox placement testing (where emails land)
• Spam filter analysis
• Email content scoring
• Deliverability testing
• DMARC monitoring (as an add-on feature)

What MailSentinel Does

MailSentinel is a dedicated DMARC monitoring platform focused on:

• DMARC aggregate and forensic report analysis
• SPF record monitoring and validation
• DKIM key management and verification
• Real-time authentication alerts
• DNS monitoring for email records

When to Choose Each Tool

Choose GlockApps If:

• You need to test where your emails land (inbox, spam, promotions)
• You want to analyze your email content and templates
• You're an email marketer focused on deliverability optimization
• You need to test against multiple ISPs and spam filters
• DMARC monitoring is a nice-to-have, not your primary need

Choose MailSentinel If:

• Your primary goal is DMARC implementation and monitoring
• You want real-time alerts when authentication fails
• You need to track all sources sending email for your domain
• You're focused on email security and spoofing prevention
• You want a simpler, more affordable solution for authentication monitoring

Feature Deep Dive

DMARC Monitoring Comparison

The Testing Gap

It's worth noting what MailSentinel doesn't do (and doesn't try to):

• ❌ Inbox placement testing
• ❌ Spam content analysis
• ❌ Email template scoring
• ❌ Multi-ISP delivery testing

If you need these capabilities, GlockApps (or similar tools) would complement MailSentinel well.

Pricing Analysis

GlockApps Pricing

GlockApps pricing is based on tests and features:

• Personal: $59/month (limited tests)
• Team: $99/month (more tests, team features)
• Agency: $249/month (unlimited tests)

DMARC monitoring is included but isn't the focus.

MailSentinel Pricing

Straightforward pricing for DMARC monitoring:

• Starter: $14/month (5 domains, full features)
• Professional: $49/month (unlimited domains)
• Enterprise: Custom pricing

Cost Comparison

If you only need DMARC monitoring:

• GlockApps: $59+/month (includes features you may not use)
• MailSentinel: $14/month (focused on what you need)

Annual savings with MailSentinel: $540+

The Best of Both Worlds

Many organizations use both tools together:

1. MailSentinel for continuous DMARC monitoring, authentication alerts, and security
2. GlockApps for periodic deliverability testing and content optimization

This combination provides comprehensive email health monitoring without overpaying for features you don't need daily.

Migration Considerations

If You're Using GlockApps for DMARC

Switching your DMARC monitoring to MailSentinel is simple:

1. Update your DMARC record to send reports to MailSentinel
2. Keep GlockApps for deliverability testing if needed
3. Save money by downgrading your GlockApps plan

v=DMARC1; p=quarantine; rua=mailto:your-id@reports.mailsentinel.io

You can send DMARC reports to multiple destinations, so testing both simultaneously is easy.

Real User Scenarios

Scenario 1: Marketing Agency

"We used GlockApps for everything, but realized we were paying $249/month mostly for DMARC monitoring. Now we use MailSentinel ($49/month) for authentication and GlockApps Personal ($59/month) just for delivery testing. Saved over $140/month."

Scenario 2: SaaS Company

"GlockApps' DMARC interface was confusing. MailSentinel's dedicated dashboard made it easy to see what sources were failing authentication and fix them quickly."

Scenario 3: E-commerce Business

"We needed real-time alerts when our transactional emails failed DMARC. GlockApps only sent weekly summaries. MailSentinel alerts us within minutes via Slack."

Summary: GlockApps vs MailSentinel

Conclusion

GlockApps and MailSentinel are both valuable tools, but they serve different primary purposes:

• GlockApps = Email testing platform with DMARC as an add-on
• MailSentinel = Dedicated DMARC monitoring with purpose-built features

If DMARC monitoring and email authentication are your priority, MailSentinel offers a more focused, affordable, and feature-rich solution.

Try MailSentinel Free →